Russian Propaganda Bots: How Automated Accounts Manipulate Global Public Opinion

6

The war in Ukraine isn’t just fought with drones and artillery. It’s being waged online, too. Specialized bots are fueling a massive Russian propaganda machine, trying to sway global public opinion in Moscow’s favor. But what exactly are these bots? How do they cause real-world damage? And what can actually be done to stop them?

Bots are computer programs designed to manufacture sentiment on social media. They are programmed to automatically create large volumes of fake profiles—accounts backed by no real human—and use them to spread disinformation and hate speech. The goal? To benefit whoever is running the code.

The Legacy of the Internet Research Agency

The result is a distorted online discourse that can radicalize users and deepen social divides. This is the finding of a research team led by Dominique Geißler at the LMU Munich. Her team investigated how intensively Russia is currently relying on bots as part of its war effort.

The question wasn’t whether Russia uses social media propaganda. Russia isn’t an untested writer in this field. The most infamous example is the Internet Research Agency (IRA). Back in 2014, during the annexation of the Crimean Peninsula, the IRA launched a massive social media campaign. The message was clear: Russia wasn’t the aggressor. Russia was in the right.

But the IRA’s reach went beyond Ukraine. They are accused of interfering in elections in other countries. They allegedly tried to influence the outcome of the 2016 US presidential election. They likely interfered in the Brexit referendum and the 2017 French presidential election as well.

A Digital Army Reaches Millions

Experts believe IRA tactics have become much more sophisticated. Since the start of the full-scale war, Russia has reportedly deployed what amounts to a literal army of programmed bots.

To understand how this online warfare works, Geißler and her colleagues analyzed nearly 350,000 pro-Russian messages posted on Twitter between February and July 2022. These were the first months of the war. They tracked posts using hashtags like #istandwithrussia.

The numbers were staggering.
* Pro-Russian posts received around 251,000 retweets in that period.
* This translated to an audience of roughly 14.4 million users.
* At least 20% of the accounts spreading these messages were bots.

By circulating pro-Russian content around the clock, these bots garnered significantly more attention than they would under normal circumstances.

Targeted and Coordinated

“In summary, our results indicate a large-scale Russian propaganda campaign on social media and highlight the new threats to society,” says Geißler.

The danger lies in the coordination. The bots don’t act randomly. They act with purpose.

The team spotted this clearly on March 2, 2022. On that day, the UN General Assembly passed a resolution officially condemning Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Not all countries signed on. Some abstained.

On that same day, Russian bot activity spiked in countries that had abstained or not signed. Nations like India, South Africa, and Pakistan saw a sudden surge in pro-Russian posts. The goal was likely to win over the populations of these undecided nations through targeted propaganda.

Hard to Stop, Hard to Track

Bots are a huge problem, but they are also slippery. Because they operate in the background, their effect on public opinion is hard to prove directly. The programmers also work in the shadows, erasing their tracks. Finding the specific people behind a bot attack is like looking for a needle in a haystack.

Geißler suggests there is only one immediate way to curb the momentum of social media propaganda: reduce the influence of bots.

Existing protection programs aimed at detecting and containing fake news could be modified. These tools don’t catch every bot, but they could minimize their impact. It’s not a cure. But it’s a start.

The bots keep running. The question is whether the filters can keep up.