Apple recently launched updated MacBook Pro models featuring the new M5 chip, alongside the latest iPad Pro and Vision Pro. However, the changes are largely internal, with minimal design or feature upgrades. For most users, this means there’s no compelling reason to upgrade from existing models or to choose the M5 Pro over the current M4 MacBook Air.
Why the M5 Doesn’t Move the Needle
The M5 offers incremental performance improvements, but these gains are unlikely to be noticeable for typical everyday tasks. The 15-inch MacBook Air with the M4 remains the superior choice for the majority of consumers, providing a balance of screen size, portability, and performance at a more attractive price point.
Air vs. Pro: A Practical Breakdown
Apple’s MacBook lineup is segmented, with the 13-inch Air catering to budget-conscious buyers and students, while the 16-inch Pro serves power users willing to pay a premium. The 14-inch Pro and 15-inch Air occupy the middle ground, but the Air offers a stronger value proposition.
Here’s why:
- Price: The 15-inch Air starts at $1,199, undercutting the $1,599 starting price of the 14-inch MacBook Pro M5. Even when upgrading the Air to a comparable 512GB SSD, it remains $200 cheaper.
- Screen Size & Portability: The 15.3-inch display of the Air provides a larger workspace without sacrificing portability. Weighing just 3.3 pounds, it’s marginally lighter than the 14-inch Pro at 3.4 pounds.
- Real-World Use: The larger screen is particularly useful for professionals juggling multiple applications, while the weight difference is negligible for everyday use.
The One Pro Advantage: ProMotion Display
The primary advantage of the MacBook Pro is its ProMotion display, offering an adaptive refresh rate of up to 120Hz. This makes scrolling smoother and text more legible. The Air’s 60Hz display, while still high quality, lacks this refinement.
However, Apple’s history suggests ProMotion may eventually trickle down to the Air models. The company recently extended this feature to its baseline iPhone, indicating a potential future update for the MacBook Air line.
The Bottom Line
For most users, the 15-inch MacBook Air with the M4 remains the smarter choice. Unless you require the absolute highest performance or prioritize a smoother scrolling experience, the Air delivers superior value, portability, and screen real estate at a lower cost. The M5 upgrade doesn’t justify the premium price for all but the most demanding users.
